Lesson 6 of 46 · Logical reasoning and problems

Arguments, conclusions and assumptions

Find the main conclusion of a short argument, tell it apart from its reasons, and name the unstated assumption the reasoning depends on.

About 20 minutes

In this lesson

  • Separate the premises, the intermediate conclusion and the main conclusion of a short argument.
  • Locate the gap between the evidence and the conclusion before reading the options.
  • Use the negation test to tell a necessary assumption from a statement that is merely helpful or too strong.

The idea

What an argument is

An argument is a group of claims in which some claims, the premises, are offered as reasons for another claim, the conclusion. A passage may also contain background: facts that set the scene but are not offered as reasons for anything. A list of facts with no "so" in it is a description, not an argument.

The logical reasoning area of the IMAT is 5 of the 60 questions. Critical-thinking questions of the kind practised here give you a short passage and ask what it concludes, what it takes for granted, or how well its reasons support it. Every one of those tasks starts with the same skill: seeing which claim is the point and which claims are the support.

Finding the conclusion

Indicator words help. "Therefore", "so", "thus", "hence", "it follows that" and "which shows that" usually come before a conclusion; "because", "since", "given that" and "as" usually come before a premise. Conclusions are often recommendations ("the hospital should…"), predictions ("cases will fall") or general claims ("exercise lowers blood pressure").

Indicators can be missing, so use the therefore test. Take two claims, join them with "therefore" in both orders, and keep the order that reads as reasoning. "Staff clean their hands more often, therefore infections passed by touch should fall" makes sense; "infections should fall, therefore staff clean their hands more often" does not. The claim after the working "therefore" is the conclusion of that step.

Main and intermediate conclusions

Longer passages chain their reasoning: a premise supports a claim, and that claim in turn supports the final point.

Role Supported by another claim? Supports another claim?
Premise No Yes
Intermediate conclusion Yes Yes
Main conclusion Yes No

The main conclusion is the one claim that supports nothing further: it is what the author wants you to accept in the end. When a question asks for the main conclusion, the intermediate conclusion is the most tempting wrong answer, because it is also argued for and often sits next to a "since" or "so".

Assumptions: the unstated premise

An assumption is a claim the argument needs but does not state. It fills the gap between what the premises establish and what the conclusion says. To find the gap, compare the words of the conclusion with the words of the premises: an idea that appears in the conclusion but nowhere in the evidence marks the place where something has been taken for granted.

Gaps come in a few familiar shapes.

  • From a link to a cause. Two things go together, so one is said to cause the other. The argument assumes the link does not run the other way and that no third factor explains both.
  • From some to all. A result in a sample is applied to a whole population. The argument assumes the sample is typical in the ways that matter.
  • From past to future. What happened before is expected to happen again. The argument assumes that conditions have not changed.
  • From one term to another. The evidence is about one thing ("fewer hospital admissions") and the conclusion about another ("better health"). The argument assumes the two go together.

The negation test

To check whether a statement is an assumption, write its opposite and ask whether the argument still stands. If the negated statement wrecks the argument, the argument needed the original: it is an assumption. If the argument survives the negation, the statement was at most helpful.

This test also exposes options that are too strong. Words such as "all", "every", "always", "only" and "the best" make a statement easy to negate without harm: the negation of "every diner is trying to lose weight" is "not every diner is", and an argument about some diners choosing differently survives that comfortably. An assumption is usually the weakest claim that still closes the gap.

A method under time pressure

  1. Read the question first, so you know whether you are looking for a conclusion or an assumption.
  2. Find the main conclusion with indicator words and the therefore test.
  3. Say the gap in your own words before you read the options.
  4. Strike out options that repeat a premise, restate the conclusion, bring in facts the argument does not use, or claim far more than the argument needs.
  5. Apply the negation test to the one or two options left.

A correct answer scores 1.5, a wrong one costs 0.4 and a blank scores 0, so elimination matters: every option you can rule out with a reason makes a final choice better informed.

Worked examples

Example 1: Main or intermediate conclusion?

Identify the main conclusion of this argument.

A hospital has placed hand-gel stations at the entrance of every ward, positioned so that nobody can walk in without passing one. Since staff now clean their hands more often, infections passed on by touch should become less common on the wards. The hospital should therefore install the same stations in its outpatient clinics.

  1. List the claims: the stations are at every ward entrance; staff clean their hands more often; infections passed by touch should become less common; the hospital should install stations in its outpatient clinics.

  2. Mark the indicators. "Since" introduces the cleaning as a reason for the claim about infections; "therefore" introduces the recommendation as the conclusion drawn from what came before.

  3. Apply the therefore test to the last two claims: "infections should become less common, therefore the hospital should install the stations in its clinics" reads as reasoning, and the reverse order does not.

  4. The claim about infections is supported (by the extra hand cleaning) and also supports something (the recommendation), so it is an intermediate conclusion. The recommendation supports nothing further, so it is the main conclusion.

Answer

The main conclusion is that the hospital should install the same stations in its outpatient clinics. The tempting wrong answer is "infections passed on by touch should become less common", which is argued for but is only a step on the way.

Example 2: The assumption behind a causal claim

In a survey of 2,000 office workers, those who usually took the stairs had lower blood pressure, on average, than those who usually took the lift. Taking the stairs therefore lowers blood pressure.

Which of these does the argument depend on? (i) Having lower blood pressure did not itself make people more likely to choose the stairs. (ii) Everyone who takes the stairs has normal blood pressure.

  1. Find the conclusion and the evidence. The conclusion is causal: taking the stairs lowers blood pressure. The evidence is only an association between stair use and lower average blood pressure.

  2. Name the gap: moving from a link to a cause. The argument needs the link not to run the other way and not to be produced by some third factor.

  3. Negate (i): "having lower blood pressure did make people more likely to choose the stairs". Then the survey result could arise without the stairs doing anything, and the conclusion loses its support. So (i) is needed.

  4. Negate (ii): "not everyone who takes the stairs has normal blood pressure". The evidence is about averages, so the argument survives this easily. (ii) is far stronger than anything the argument needs.

Answer

The argument assumes (i). Statement (ii) is tempting because it sounds as if it supports the conclusion, but it is a sweeping claim the argument never relies on.

Example 3: Only what the conclusion needs

A new reading programme was tried in five primary schools, and pupils' reading-test scores rose in all five. If the region introduces the programme in all its primary schools, reading-test scores across the region will rise.

Which of these does the argument assume? (i) The five schools were not unusual in ways that made the programme work there. (ii) Reading-test scores are an accurate measure of how well pupils read.

  1. The conclusion predicts higher reading-test scores across the region; the evidence is a rise in five schools. The new idea in the conclusion is "all the region's schools", so the gap is from some to all.

  2. Negate (i): the five schools were unusual in ways that made the programme work there. Then nothing follows about the other schools, and the prediction collapses. So (i) is an assumption.

  3. Negate (ii): test scores are not an accurate measure of reading. The conclusion is about scores, not about reading ability, so it still follows from the evidence. (ii) is not needed.

Answer

The argument assumes (i). Statement (ii) would matter only if the conclusion claimed that pupils read better; choosing it means reading more into the conclusion than it says.

Common traps

  • Choosing the intermediate conclusion

    In a chained argument the intermediate conclusion is argued for, often stands next to "so" or "since", and sounds like a conclusion. Check whether it goes on to support another claim; if it does, it is not the main conclusion. The main conclusion is the end of the chain.

  • Picking an assumption that is too strong

    Options with "all", "always", "only" or "the best" are attractive because they would make the conclusion certain. An assumption does not need to make the conclusion certain; it needs to be something the argument cannot do without. Negate the option: if the argument survives, it was not assumed.

  • Answering from outside knowledge

    An option can be true, sensible and medically correct and still not be an assumption of this argument. Judge every option only by whether this passage's reasoning needs it. What you know about the topic from elsewhere does not count.

  • Mistaking a premise for an assumption

    An assumption is unstated. An option that repeats something the passage already says is a premise, not an assumption, however central it is. If you can underline it in the passage, it is not the answer to an assumption question.

Check yourself

Choose an answer to each question: you will see at once whether it is right, and why.

Question 1: The pharmacist argument

Critical thinking: main conclusion

Many patients stop taking their blood-pressure tablets once they feel well. Yet high blood pressure rarely causes symptoms, so feeling well tells a patient nothing about whether the tablets are still needed. Pharmacists who hand over these tablets should therefore remind each patient that the treatment must continue even when there are no symptoms.

Which of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument?

Show the answer

Answer: D. Pharmacists should remind patients collecting blood-pressure tablets that treatment must continue without symptoms.

Working

The chain runs: high blood pressure rarely causes symptoms, so feeling well says nothing about whether treatment is needed, therefore pharmacists should remind patients to continue. The claim about feeling well is supported and also supports the recommendation, so it is intermediate. The recommendation to pharmacists supports nothing further: it is the main conclusion.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A. This is background that sets up the problem; nothing in the passage argues for it, and it is not what the passage wants you to accept in the end.
  • B. This is a premise: it is given as a reason ("so…") and is not supported by anything else in the passage.
  • C. This is an intermediate conclusion. It is supported by the premise about symptoms, but it in turn supports the recommendation to pharmacists.
  • E. The passage never says this. It is a stronger claim about consequences that the argument neither states nor needs.

What carries over

The main conclusion is the claim that supports nothing else; a claim that is argued for and then used again is intermediate.

Question 2: The helmet law

Critical thinking: assumption

In the year after a town made helmets compulsory for cyclists, the number of cyclists treated at the town's hospital for head injuries fell by a third. The law has therefore reduced head injuries among the town's cyclists.

Which of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?

Show the answer

Answer: B. The number of people cycling in the town did not fall sharply in the year after the law was introduced.

Working

The evidence is a fall in the number of cyclists treated for head injuries; the conclusion is that the law caused fewer head injuries. If far fewer people cycled after the law, the number of injuries could fall for that reason alone. Negate the statement about cycling: "the number of people cycling fell sharply". The fall in injuries is then explained without the helmets, and the argument collapses, so the argument depends on it.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A. Far too strong. The argument needs helmets to prevent some injuries, not all of them; negating this ("helmets do not prevent every head injury") leaves the argument standing.
  • C. The argument does not need this; if anything, the law could only have had an effect if many cyclists did not wear helmets before. Negating it does no harm to the argument.
  • D. How common head injuries are compared with other injuries is irrelevant to whether the law reduced head injuries.
  • E. This is a further conclusion someone might draw, not something the argument relies on.

What carries over

When a count falls, ask whether the number of people at risk fell too; an argument from a count assumes it did not.

Question 3: Calories on the menu

Critical thinking: assumption

From next month, the hospital canteen's menu will show the number of calories in every dish. Diners at the canteen will therefore choose lower-calorie meals than they do now.

Which of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?

Show the answer

Answer: C. At least some diners will notice the calorie figures and let them affect what they choose.

Working

The gap is between showing the calories and diners choosing differently. Negate the statement about noticing: "no diner will both notice the figures and let them affect the choice". Then showing the calories changes nothing and the conclusion fails, so the argument depends on it. The statements about every diner dieting and about health go beyond what the conclusion says.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A. Too strong. The argument needs only some diners to change their choices; negating this ("not every diner is trying to lose weight") leaves it intact.
  • B. The conclusion is about what diners will choose, not about health, so the argument does not need this, true or not.
  • D. The dishes themselves are not said to change; the argument is about the effect of showing their calories, so their past content is irrelevant.
  • E. This would weaken the argument. An assumption is something the argument needs to be true, not evidence against it.

What carries over

An assumption is usually the weakest claim that closes the gap; test it by negating it.

Flashcards

Recall the answer before you flip each card, then say whether you knew it. Cards you miss come back at the end.

Premise
A claim offered as a reason for another claim. It is stated in the passage and is not itself argued for.
Intermediate conclusion
A claim that is supported by a premise and in turn supports the main conclusion. It is the most tempting wrong answer to a main-conclusion question.
The therefore test
Join two claims with "therefore" in both orders. The order that reads as reasoning shows which claim is the conclusion of that step.
Assumption
An unstated claim the argument needs: without it the evidence no longer supports the conclusion.
The negation test
Write the opposite of a candidate assumption. If the argument collapses, the statement was assumed; if it survives, it was not.
Four common gaps
From a link to a cause, from some to all, from past to future, and from one term to another.

Key points

  • The main conclusion supports nothing further; an intermediate conclusion is argued for and then used again.

  • Use indicator words and the therefore test to find which claim is the point.

  • An assumption is unstated and necessary: it fills the gap between the evidence and the conclusion.

  • Negate a candidate assumption: if the argument collapses, it was assumed; if it survives, it was not.

All questions here are original and written for UniExamer; none comes from the test maker.

Written and reviewed by the UniExamer education and assessment team. Every worked example and check question was checked before publication. If you find a mistake, write to support@uniexamer.com.

Practise this topic

Fresh questions on this skill, with worked explanations. Practice needs a Single Exam Pass or Plus.