Lesson 4 of 46 · Reading skills and knowledge
Inference and assumptions in texts
Tell what a text states, what must follow from it and what it silently assumes, and use the negation test to find the assumption an argument needs.
About 18 minutes
In this lesson
- Distinguish a statement, an inference that must be true, and a plausible guess.
- Find the unstated assumption an argument relies on, and check it with the negation test.
- Handle "all", "only", "most" and "some" correctly when drawing conclusions.
The idea
Stated, inferred, assumed
Questions about a text ask about three different relationships, and confusing them is the commonest source of wrong answers.
- Stated: the text says it, perhaps in other words.
- Inferred: the text does not say it, but it must be true if everything in the text is true.
- Assumed: the text does not say it, but an argument in the text needs it in order to reach its conclusion.
An inference follows from the text. An assumption sits underneath an argument, filling the gap between its evidence and its conclusion.
The "must be true" test
For an inference question ("Which of the following can be inferred?", "Which must be true?"), the standard is strict. The right option must hold in every situation consistent with the text. A plausible, likely or sensible conclusion is not enough.
Test each option by trying to imagine a situation where the text is true and the option is false. If you can, the option is not an inference. For example, "Every patient on the morning list had a blood test; Mr Rossi had no blood test this morning" lets you infer that Mr Rossi was not on the morning list. It does not let you infer that he was discharged, or that he refused the test: those may be true, but the text is equally true if they are false.
Words that set the logic
Some words do most of the work in inference questions:
| Word | What it means | A common misreading |
|---|---|---|
| all, every | no exceptions | reading it backwards ("all A are B" does not give "all B are A") |
| only | a necessary condition | treating it as sufficient ("open only when a doctor is present" does not mean "open whenever a doctor is present") |
| most | more than half | reading it as "almost all" |
| some | at least one | reading it as "some but not all" |
| none | no exceptions, in the negative | forgetting it also rules out the reverse ("no A is B" does give "no B is A") |
"Most" has a useful consequence. If more than half of a group has property P and more than half has property Q, the two halves cannot fit side by side without overlapping, so at least one member has both.
Finding an assumption
An argument moves from evidence to a conclusion. To find its assumption, state the evidence and the conclusion in a few words each and look at the gap: what new idea appears in the conclusion that the evidence never mentioned? The assumption links the two.
Arguments in scientific texts often move from a correlation to a cause, or from one group to another. Typical assumptions are therefore:
- that nothing else explains the result (no other cause);
- that the cause did not run the other way;
- that the group studied is like the group the conclusion talks about;
- that a measure really captures what it claims to measure.
The negation test
Once you have a candidate assumption, negate it, that is, state its opposite, and put the negation next to the argument. If the argument collapses, the statement was an assumption the argument needs. If the argument is untouched, the statement was not necessary, however reasonable it sounds.
Negate carefully. The negation of "all students drink coffee" is "at least one student does not", not "no student does". The negation of "the walking caused the fall" is "the walking did not cause the fall".
Common wrong options
- Too strong. An assumption only has to be as strong as the argument needs. "Coffee is the only cause of poor sleep" is stronger than an argument about coffee needs.
- Supports but is not needed. An option may make the conclusion more likely without being required. The negation test separates the two.
- Restates the conclusion or the evidence. Something already written is not an unstated assumption.
- Out of scope. A true statement about a related topic.
A method
- Decide which relationship the question asks for: stated, inferred or assumed.
- For an inference, apply the "must be true" test to each option.
- For an assumption, name the evidence, the conclusion and the gap, then use the negation test on the options that address the gap.
Worked examples
Example 1: An inference from "only"
Text: "The laboratory's freezer alarm sounds only when the temperature rises above −70 °C. On Saturday night the alarm did not sound."
Which follows: (i) "On Saturday night the temperature did not rise above −70 °C", or (ii) "Whenever the temperature rises above −70 °C, the alarm sounds"?
"Only when" gives a necessary condition: if the alarm sounds, the temperature has risen above −70 °C.
Statement (ii) turns this round into "if the temperature rises, the alarm sounds". The text does not say that; an alarm could fail to sound even after a rise. So (ii) is not an inference.
Statement (i) also does not follow. The alarm not sounding is consistent with the temperature staying below −70 °C, and equally with a rise that the alarm missed. The text is true in both cases.
Answer
Neither follows. "Only when" says what must have happened if the alarm sounds; it says nothing about what happens when it does not. Choosing (i) is the tempting mistake, because it treats the alarm as a guaranteed signal.
Example 2: The assumption behind a before-and-after argument
Argument: "Hand-sanitiser stations were installed at every ward entrance in March. Infections acquired in the hospital between March and June were fewer than in the same months last year. So the stations reduced infections."
What does the argument assume?
Evidence: stations installed, and fewer infections afterwards than a year earlier. Conclusion: the stations caused the fall.
The gap: the conclusion names a cause, while the evidence shows only that two things happened at the same time.
Candidate assumption: no other change between the two periods, such as fewer patients or a new cleaning routine, explains the fall.
Negation test: "another change explains the fall". If that were true, the stations might have done nothing, and the argument collapses. So the candidate is a real assumption.
Answer
The argument assumes that nothing else explains the drop in infections. A tempting but wrong choice would be "staff used the stations every time they entered a ward": that would strengthen the argument, but the conclusion could still hold if staff used them most of the time, so it is not required.
Example 3: Two "most" statements
Text: "Most of the 30 students in the group passed the biology test. Most of them also passed the chemistry test." Must at least one student have passed both tests?
"Most" means more than half. More than half of 30 is at least 16, so at least 16 passed biology and at least 16 passed chemistry.
If no student passed both, the two groups would be separate, and together they would contain at least students. The group has only 30.
So the groups must overlap by at least students.
Answer
Yes: at least two students passed both. What does not follow is that most of the biology passers also passed chemistry; the overlap could be as small as 2.
Common traps
Choosing the likely instead of the certain
Inference questions reward the option that must be true, not the one that is probably true. If you can imagine the text being true and the option false, reject the option, however sensible it sounds.
Reading "only" as "whenever"
"A happens only if B" means B is needed for A. It does not mean B is enough for A. Rewrite "only if" sentences as "if A, then B" before you use them.
Picking a strengthener as the assumption
Many options make an argument stronger without being necessary. Negate the option: if the argument survives the negation, the option was not an assumption.
Check yourself
Choose an answer to each question: you will see at once whether it is right, and why.
Question 1: When is the clinic open?
Inference
The clinic opens only on days when both a doctor and a nurse are present. Dr Bianchi is the clinic's only doctor, and she works there only on Tuesdays and Thursdays. A nurse is present every weekday.
If the statements above are true, which of the following must also be true?
Show the answer
Answer: B. The clinic is never open on a Monday.
Working
Opening requires a doctor. The only doctor works only on Tuesdays and Thursdays, so on a Monday no doctor is present and the clinic cannot open. This holds in every situation consistent with the text. Nothing guarantees that the clinic opens on the days when both are present.
Why the other options are wrong
- A. Having a doctor and a nurse present is required for opening, not a guarantee of it; "only on days when" gives a necessary condition.
- C. A nurse is present every weekday, including Mondays, when the clinic cannot open; this must be false.
- D. Dr Bianchi, the only doctor, never works on Saturdays, so the clinic can never open then; this must be false.
- E. The text says she works there only on Tuesdays and Thursdays; this contradicts it.
What carries over
A necessary condition tells you when something cannot happen, never when it must.
Question 2: Coffee and sleep
Assumption
A survey at a university found that students who drink coffee in the evening sleep fewer hours, on average, than students who do not. Therefore, if the students who drink coffee in the evening stopped doing so, they would sleep longer.
The argument above depends on which of the following assumptions?
Show the answer
Answer: D. The shorter sleep is caused by the evening coffee, not by something that also leads students to drink it, such as studying late.
Working
Evidence: evening coffee drinkers sleep less on average. Conclusion: stopping the coffee would lengthen their sleep. The gap is from a correlation to a cause. Negate the key option: "the shorter sleep is caused by something else, such as studying late, which also leads students to drink coffee". Then stopping the coffee would change nothing, and the argument collapses.
Why the other options are wrong
- A. The survey compares students who do and do not drink evening coffee, so the argument cannot need all of them to drink it.
- B. Popularity has no bearing on whether stopping would lengthen sleep; the negation leaves the argument intact.
- C. This is consistent with the survey but not needed; if it were false, the argument would be untouched or even stronger.
- E. This is outside the argument, which concludes only that the students would sleep longer, not that they would perform better.
What carries over
When an argument moves from "goes with" to "causes", it assumes that nothing else explains the link.
Question 3: Overlapping majorities
Inference
More than half of the 40 volunteers in a study were vegetarians. More than half of the 40 volunteers exercised every day.
Which of the following must be true?
Show the answer
Answer: A. At least one volunteer was a vegetarian who exercised every day.
Working
More than half of 40 means at least 21. If the two groups did not overlap, they would contain at least people, more than the 40 volunteers. So at least volunteers belong to both groups, and in particular at least one does.
Why the other options are wrong
- B. The overlap is guaranteed but may be as small as 2 volunteers out of 21 or more vegetarians, so "most" does not follow.
- C. Two groups of at least 21 cannot fit into 40 people without overlapping; this must be false.
- D. The text fixes no exact figure for the overlap; many different splits fit it.
- E. The text gives counts for one group, not a cause or a general tendency.
What carries over
Two "more than half" groups in the same set must share at least one member.
Flashcards
Recall the answer before you flip each card, then say whether you knew it. Cards you miss come back at the end.
- Inference
- A statement that must be true if everything in the text is true. It must hold in every situation consistent with the text.
- Assumption
- An unstated idea that an argument needs to get from its evidence to its conclusion.
- The negation test
- State the opposite of a candidate assumption. If the argument then collapses, the statement was an assumption it needs.
- "A only if B"
- B is necessary for A: if A happens, B holds. It does not say that B is enough for A.
- "Most" and "some"
- "Most" means more than half. "Some" means at least one, and does not rule out all.
- Typical assumption in a cause argument
- That nothing else explains the result, and that the cause does not run the other way.
Key points
An inference must be true in every situation consistent with the text; "probably true" is not enough.
"Only if" gives a necessary condition: it says when something cannot happen.
An assumption fills the gap between evidence and conclusion; check it with the negation test.
Two groups that each contain more than half of the same set must overlap.
All questions here are original and written for UniExamer; none comes from the test maker.
Written and reviewed by the UniExamer education and assessment team. Every worked example and check question was checked before publication. If you find a mistake, write to support@uniexamer.com.