Lesson 19 of 46 · Biology

Mutations, evolution and classification

Classify mutations by their effect, explain how selection and drift change populations, use Hardy–Weinberg, and place organisms in the taxonomic hierarchy.

About 24 minutes

In this lesson

  • Classify gene, chromosome and genome mutations and predict their effect on a protein or a karyotype.
  • Explain natural selection, genetic drift and speciation, and use the Hardy–Weinberg equations.
  • Order the taxonomic ranks and write a species name correctly.

The idea

Gene mutations

A mutation is a permanent change in the DNA sequence. Mutations arise from copying errors during replication or from mutagens: ionising radiation, ultraviolet light and some chemicals. Only mutations in the germ line (the cells that make gametes) pass to offspring; a somatic mutation affects the individual and the cells descended from the mutated one.

A point mutation changes one nucleotide. Because the genetic code is read in triplets and is degenerate (most amino acids have more than one codon), a substitution can have three effects:

Type What changes Typical effect
Silent The new codon codes for the same amino acid None on the protein
Missense The new codon codes for a different amino acid Anything from none to severe, as in sickle-cell anaemia
Nonsense The new codon is a stop codon A shortened protein, usually non-functional

Insertions and deletions of one or two nucleotides cause a frameshift: every codon after the change is read in a new frame, so the amino acid sequence from that point on is altered and a stop codon usually turns up early. Adding or removing exactly three nucleotides keeps the frame: it adds or removes one amino acid (and, if the change spans two codons, may also alter a neighbouring one).

Chromosome and genome mutations

Larger changes affect the structure of chromosomes: deletion (a segment lost), duplication (a segment repeated), inversion (a segment reversed) and translocation (a segment moved to a non-homologous chromosome). Changes in the number of chromosomes usually come from nondisjunction, the failure of homologous chromosomes (in meiosis I) or sister chromatids (in meiosis II) to separate. A gamete with an extra or a missing chromosome then gives a zygote with aneuploidy: trisomy 21 (Down syndrome, 47 chromosomes), Klinefelter syndrome (47,XXY) or Turner syndrome (45,X). Having whole extra sets of chromosomes is polyploidy, common in plants.

Natural selection

Darwin's argument rests on observations that can each be checked:

  1. Organisms produce more offspring than can survive.
  2. Individuals of a species vary, and much of the variation is heritable.
  3. Individuals whose heritable traits suit the environment survive and reproduce more.
  4. So those traits become more common in the next generation.

Selection acts on individuals, but it is populations that evolve, as allele frequencies change over generations. A trait acquired during a lifetime, such as a muscle built by training, is not inherited. New variation comes from mutation; meiosis (crossing over and independent assortment) and random fertilisation reshuffle it. Selection can be directional (one extreme favoured), stabilising (the average favoured, as in human birth weight) or disruptive (both extremes favoured).

Other causes of evolution

  • Genetic drift: random changes in allele frequency, strongest in small populations. A bottleneck (a population shrinks sharply) and the founder effect (a few individuals start a new population) are special cases.
  • Gene flow: migration carries alleles between populations and makes them more alike.
  • Mutation adds new alleles, slowly.

Hardy–Weinberg

For a gene with two alleles at frequencies pp (dominant) and qq (recessive):

p+q=1p2+2pq+q2=1p + q = 1 \qquad p^2 + 2pq + q^2 = 1

p2p^2, 2pq2pq and q2q^2 are the frequencies of AA, Aa and aa. The frequencies stay constant from one generation to the next only if the population is very large, mating is random, and there is no mutation, migration or selection. The usual move is to start from q2q^2, the frequency of people showing the recessive trait, because that is the only genotype you can see.

Species and speciation

In the biological species concept, a species is a group of populations whose members can interbreed and produce fertile offspring. A male donkey and a female horse produce a mule, which is sterile, so horses and donkeys are separate species. New species form when gene flow between populations stops: allopatric speciation follows a geographical barrier; sympatric speciation happens in the same place, for example by polyploidy in plants.

Evidence for evolution includes fossils, homologous structures (the same basic structure adapted to different uses, like the forelimbs of humans, whales and bats, showing common ancestry), vestigial structures, and comparisons of DNA and protein sequences. Analogous structures, like the wings of insects and birds, do the same job but evolved separately, so they are not evidence of close kinship.

Classification

Living things are grouped in nested ranks, from the most inclusive to the least: domain, kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species. There are three domains: Bacteria, Archaea and Eukarya. Organisms that share a rank share every rank above it. Each species has a two-part (binomial) name, introduced by Linnaeus: the genus with a capital letter, then the specific name in lower case, both in italics, as in Homo sapiens.

Worked examples

Example 1: Three changes to one gene

The coding part of an mRNA begins AUG UUU UGG GGC..., where AUG is the start codon (AUG codes for methionine, UUU and UUC for phenylalanine, UGG for tryptophan; UGA is a stop codon). Classify each change: (a) UUU becomes UUC; (b) UGG becomes UGA; (c) the U at the start of the third codon is deleted.

  1. (a) UUC still codes for phenylalanine, so the protein is unchanged: a silent mutation, possible because the code is degenerate.

  2. (b) UGA is a stop codon, so translation ends after phenylalanine: a nonsense mutation giving a protein two amino acids long instead of the full length.

  3. (c) Removing one base shifts the reading frame. The sequence now reads AUG UUU GGG GC..., so from the third codon onwards every codon is read in the new frame: a frameshift.

  4. Check (c) by counting: one deleted base is not a multiple of three, so the frame is not restored, and all the downstream codons are read in the shifted frame.

Answer

(a) silent, (b) nonsense, (c) frameshift. Calling (b) a missense mutation is the common slip: a missense mutation swaps one amino acid, whereas a stop codon cuts the protein short.

Example 2: How common are carriers?

An autosomal recessive condition affects 1 person in 2,500 in a population in Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium. What fraction of the population are carriers?

  1. Affected people are aa, so q2=12500q^2 = \frac{1}{2500}.

  2. Take the square root: q=150=0.02q = \frac{1}{50} = 0.02. Then p=1−q=0.98p = 1 - q = 0.98.

  3. Carriers are Aa, with frequency 2pq=2×0.98×0.02=0.03922pq = 2 \times 0.98 \times 0.02 = 0.0392.

  4. Check with an approximation: when qq is small, p≈1p \approx 1, so 2pq≈2q=0.042pq \approx 2q = 0.04, which agrees. That is about 1 person in 25.

Answer

About 3.9%3.9\% of people, roughly 1 in 25, are carriers, far more than the 1 in 2,500 who are affected. Answering q=0.02q = 0.02 gives the frequency of the allele, not of carriers.

Example 3: Nondisjunction in meiosis I

During meiosis I in a woman, the two copies of chromosome 21 fail to separate. What chromosome numbers can the gametes from this division have, and what numbers result if one of them is fertilised by a normal sperm?

  1. Normally each gamete gets one chromosome 21 and 23 chromosomes in all.

  2. If both homologues go to the same pole in meiosis I, one secondary cell has two chromosome 21s and the other has none. Meiosis II then separates chromatids normally.

  3. So the gametes have 24 chromosomes (two 21s) or 22 (no 21). None is normal.

  4. Add the 23 chromosomes of a normal sperm: 24+23=4724 + 23 = 47 (trisomy 21) or 22+23=4522 + 23 = 45 (monosomy 21).

Answer

Gametes with 24 or 22 chromosomes; zygotes with 47 (trisomy 21, Down syndrome) or 45. Nondisjunction in meiosis II instead would leave half the products of meiosis normal.

Common traps

  • Calling every mutation harmful

    Many mutations are silent or neutral, and a few are beneficial; that is what selection acts on. Judge a mutation by its effect on the protein, not by the word "mutation".

  • Thinking individuals evolve

    An animal that stretches or trains does not pass the change on. Evolution is a change in the allele frequencies of a population across generations; selection only sorts the variation that is already heritable.

  • Using q when the question asks for carriers

    From q2q^2 you get qq, the allele frequency. Carriers are 2pq2pq. Write down which of pp, qq, p2p^2, 2pq2pq and q2q^2 the question wants before you calculate.

  • Taking analogous structures as evidence of kinship

    Wings of birds and insects do the same job but are built differently: that is convergent evolution. Homologous structures, built on the same plan, are the evidence of common ancestry.

Check yourself

Choose an answer to each question: you will see at once whether it is right, and why.

Question 1: Which mutation changes the most?

Mutations and evolution

Which mutation in the coding sequence of a gene is most likely to change the identity of most of the amino acids encoded after the mutation site?

Show the answer

Answer: B. The deletion of a single nucleotide near the start of the coding sequence

Working

A single deleted nucleotide shifts the reading frame, so every codon after it is read differently and the amino acids from there on change (until an early stop codon is usually met). Silent, missense and in-frame changes affect at most one amino acid, and a nonsense mutation removes the downstream amino acids rather than changing them.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A. This is a silent mutation: the amino acid stays the same, and nothing downstream changes.
  • C. Removing three bases keeps the reading frame: one amino acid is lost and the rest are unchanged.
  • D. A nonsense mutation stops translation, so the downstream amino acids are missing, not changed into others.
  • E. A missense mutation changes one amino acid only; the reading frame is untouched.

What carries over

Only a frameshift alters every codon after the mutation; in-frame changes stay local.

Question 2: Heterozygotes from a phenotype frequency

Mutations and evolution

In a population in Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium, 16% of individuals show a recessive phenotype. What is the frequency of heterozygotes?

Show the answer

Answer: E. 0.48

Working

q2=0.16q^2 = 0.16, so q=0.4q = 0.4 and p=0.6p = 0.6. Heterozygotes: 2pq=2×0.6×0.4=0.482pq = 2 \times 0.6 \times 0.4 = 0.48. Check that the genotypes add to 1: 0.36+0.48+0.16=10.36 + 0.48 + 0.16 = 1.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A. This is q2q^2, the frequency of the recessive homozygotes already given.
  • B. This is pq=0.6×0.4pq = 0.6 \times 0.4; the heterozygote frequency is twice that.
  • C. This is p2p^2, the frequency of the dominant homozygotes.
  • D. This is qq, the frequency of the recessive allele, not of a genotype.

What carries over

Start from q2q^2, take the root, then build pp, p2p^2 and 2pq2pq; check that they add to 1.

Question 3: Same order, different families

Mutations and evolution

Two animal species belong to the same order but to different families. Which statement must be true?

Show the answer

Answer: A. They belong to the same class.

Working

The ranks run domain, kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species, each nested inside the one before it. Two species in the same order therefore share its class, phylum, kingdom and domain. Being in different families, they must also be in different genera.

Why the other options are wrong

  • B. A genus sits inside a family, so species in different families cannot share a genus.
  • C. Sharing an order means sharing every rank above it, phylum included.
  • D. The class is above the order, so species in one order are in one class.
  • E. Kingdom is above order; both species are in the same kingdom, here the animals.

What carries over

Organisms that share a rank share every rank above it, and differ at every rank below the one where they split.

Flashcards

Recall the answer before you flip each card, then say whether you knew it. Cards you miss come back at the end.

Silent, missense and nonsense mutations
Silent: the new codon codes for the same amino acid. Missense: a different amino acid. Nonsense: a stop codon, so the protein is cut short.
Frameshift
The insertion or deletion of a number of nucleotides that is not a multiple of three; every codon after it is read in a new frame.
Nondisjunction
The failure of homologous chromosomes (meiosis I) or sister chromatids (meiosis II) to separate, giving gametes with one chromosome too many or too few.
Hardy–Weinberg equations and conditions
p+q=1p + q = 1 and p2+2pq+q2=1p^2 + 2pq + q^2 = 1. They hold in a very large, randomly mating population with no mutation, migration or selection.
Genetic drift
Random change in allele frequencies, strongest in small populations; bottlenecks and the founder effect are examples.
The taxonomic ranks in order
Domain, kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species, from the most inclusive to the least.

Key points

  • Substitutions can be silent, missense or nonsense; insertions or deletions that are not multiples of three cause frameshifts.

  • Nondisjunction gives gametes with an extra or missing chromosome, and so trisomies and monosomies.

  • Selection acts on heritable variation in individuals; populations evolve, through selection, drift, gene flow and mutation.

  • Hardy–Weinberg: start from q2q^2, the recessive phenotype, and carriers are 2pq2pq.

  • Domain, kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species; names are written as Genus species.

All questions here are original and written for UniExamer; none comes from the test maker.

Written and reviewed by the UniExamer education and assessment team. Every worked example and check question was checked before publication. If you find a mistake, write to support@uniexamer.com.

Practise this topic

Fresh questions on this skill, with worked explanations. Practice needs a Single Exam Pass or Plus.