Lesson 8 of 46 · Logical reasoning and problems

Numerical problem solving without a calculator

Set up word problems on doses, rates, proportions and overlapping groups, and solve them by hand with fractions, friendly numbers and quick checks.

About 22 minutes

In this lesson

  • Turn a word problem into a short chain of quantities with their units.
  • Solve rate, proportion and overlapping-group problems by hand, using fractions rather than long decimals.
  • Check an answer by a second route and spot the intermediate quantity that a wrong option offers.

The idea

What these problems test

Problem-solving questions describe an everyday or scientific situation in words and ask for a number. The arithmetic is simple; the difficulty is in setting up the right chain of quantities and not stopping halfway. Nothing in the IMAT rules allows a calculator, so plan to work by hand.

Write the chain before you calculate

Read the question sentence first and write down what is wanted, with its unit: "mL per dose", "km/h", "number of students". Then list the given quantities with their units and look for the chain that links them. Units are your guide: mg per kg times kg gives mg; mg divided by mg per mL gives mL. If the units of your final step do not match what is asked, the set-up is wrong before any arithmetic has gone wrong.

Arithmetic that suits working by hand

  • Fractions beat decimals. 35\frac{3}{5} of something is easier to handle than 0.60.6 of it, and 14×35=320\frac{1}{4} \times \frac{3}{5} = \frac{3}{20} stays exact.
  • Cancel before you multiply. 36×203\frac{36 \times 20}{3} is 12×20=24012 \times 20 = 240; there is no need to work out 720720 first.
  • Friendly numbers. 15×24=15×4×6=60×6=36015 \times 24 = 15 \times 4 \times 6 = 60 \times 6 = 360.
  • Estimate first. A rough size lets you rule out options that are ten times too big or that lie outside the obvious range.

Rates

A rate is an amount per unit of time (or per unit of something else). Three patterns cover most problems.

  1. Distance, speed and time: d=v×td = v \times t. Keep hours with km/h; 45 minutes is 34\frac{3}{4} h.
  2. Average speed: total distance divided by total time. It is not the average of the speeds, because more time is spent at the lower speed.
  3. Working together: if one person finishes a job in aa hours and another in bb hours, their rates are 1a\frac{1}{a} and 1b\frac{1}{b} jobs per hour, and rates add: together they do 1a+1b\frac{1}{a} + \frac{1}{b} jobs per hour. Times never add.

Proportions and parts of a whole

When a question gives a fraction of a fraction ("three fifths of the patients are adults, and a quarter of the adults are over 65"), multiply the fractions to get the share of the whole: 35×14=320\frac{3}{5} \times \frac{1}{4} = \frac{3}{20}. If you know the size of the part, divide by its share to find the whole. A ratio of 1:41 : 4 means 1 part out of 1+4=51 + 4 = 5 parts, not 1 part out of 4.

Overlapping groups

For two groups that overlap,

total=A+B−both+neither\text{total} = A + B - \text{both} + \text{neither}

Adding AA and BB counts the people in both groups twice, so they are taken away once. A small table or a two-circle diagram makes the four regions visible: only AA, only BB, both, neither.

Working backwards from the options

With five numerical options, it is sometimes quicker to test them than to solve. Start with a middle-sized option: if it gives too large a result, the answer is smaller, and two or three options go at once. This works best when the forward calculation is awkward but checking a single number is easy, as in "how many tablets were in the box at the start?" problems where each day removes a fixed fraction.

Counting intervals

When events repeat at fixed intervals, the number of events is one more than the number of gaps between the first and the last. Tablets every 8 hours from 06:00 on Monday to 22:00 on Tuesday cover 40 hours, which is 5 gaps and therefore 6 tablets. Draw a short timeline whenever you are unsure whether to add the one.

Checking an answer

A second route catches most slips. Run the answer forwards through the problem: if the answer is a total of 240 patients, does 320\frac{3}{20} of 240 really give the 36 you were told? Also look at the options for the numbers you met on the way: wrong options are often the intermediate results of the right method (the daily dose instead of the single dose, the number of adults instead of all patients). If your answer is one of those, check that you finished.

Worked examples

Example 1: Volume of one dose

A fictional prescription gives a child 15 mg of a medicine per kg of body mass per day, split into 3 equal doses. The child's mass is 24 kg, and the liquid medicine contains 120 mg in every 5 mL. What volume should each dose be?

  1. Write the chain with units: mg per kg per day × kg → mg per day; ÷ 3 → mg per dose; ÷ (mg per mL) → mL per dose.

  2. Daily amount: 15×24=36015 \times 24 = 360 mg.

  3. One dose: 360÷3=120360 \div 3 = 120 mg.

  4. The liquid has 120 mg in 5 mL, so 120 mg is exactly 5 mL.

  5. Check by another route: the daily volume is 360120×5=15\frac{360}{120} \times 5 = 15 mL, and 15÷3=515 \div 3 = 5 mL per dose.

Answer

Each dose is 5 mL. The tempting wrong answer is 15 mL, which is the volume for the whole day.

Example 2: Working together

One technician can pack a box of test kits in 20 minutes; a second takes 30 minutes for the same job. Working together at these rates, how long do they take to pack 5 boxes?

  1. Turn times into rates: 120\frac{1}{20} and 130\frac{1}{30} of a box per minute.

  2. Rates add: 120+130=360+260=560=112\frac{1}{20} + \frac{1}{30} = \frac{3}{60} + \frac{2}{60} = \frac{5}{60} = \frac{1}{12} box per minute.

  3. At one box every 12 minutes, 5 boxes take 5×12=605 \times 12 = 60 minutes.

  4. Check: in 60 minutes the first packs 60÷20=360 \div 20 = 3 boxes and the second 60÷30=260 \div 30 = 2, which is 5 boxes.

Answer

They take 60 minutes. Averaging the times (25 minutes per box, so 125 minutes) or adding them are the tempting wrong methods: times do not add or average, rates add.

Example 3: Overlapping groups

Of 120 students, 70 study biology, 50 study chemistry and 20 study neither. How many study both subjects?

  1. Students who study at least one subject: 120−20=100120 - 20 = 100.

  2. Adding the two subjects gives 70+50=12070 + 50 = 120, which is 20 more than 100, because everyone who studies both has been counted twice.

  3. So 2020 students study both. Check with the four regions: biology only 70−20=5070 - 20 = 50, chemistry only 50−20=3050 - 20 = 30, both 20, neither 20, and 50+30+20+20=12050 + 30 + 20 + 20 = 120.

Answer

20 students study both subjects. Forgetting the 20 who study neither leads to 70+50−120=070 + 50 - 120 = 0, the tempting wrong answer.

Common traps

  • Averaging speeds

    Going 60 km/h one way and 40 km/h back does not average 50 km/h: the slower leg takes longer, so it counts for more. Average speed is always total distance divided by total time.

  • Mixing units

    Minutes with km/h, mL with L, or mg with g produce answers out by a factor of 60 or 1,000. Convert everything into the units of the answer before calculating, and check the unit of each step.

  • Stopping at an intermediate result

    The daily dose, the number of adults, the time for one box: each is a step on the way, and each is likely to appear among the options. Reread the question sentence before you choose.

  • Misreading a ratio

    A ratio of 1:41 : 4 is 1 part in 5, not 1 part in 4. Add the parts of the ratio to get the whole before you divide.

Check yourself

Choose an answer to each question: you will see at once whether it is right, and why.

Question 1: There and back

Problem solving: rates

A paramedic drives 30 km to a hospital at an average speed of 60 km/h and returns by the same route at an average speed of 40 km/h. What is the average speed for the whole round trip?

Show the answer

Answer: B. 48 km/h

Working

Time out: 3060=0.5\frac{30}{60} = 0.5 h. Time back: 3040=0.75\frac{30}{40} = 0.75 h. Total: 60 km in 1.25 h, so the average speed is 601.25=48\frac{60}{1.25} = 48 km/h. Second route: for equal distances the average speed is 2×60×4060+40=4800100=48\frac{2 \times 60 \times 40}{60 + 40} = \frac{4800}{100} = 48 km/h.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A. This divides only the one-way distance, 30 km, by the total time of 1.25 hours; the round trip is 60 km.
  • C. This is the average of the two speeds. More time is spent at 40 km/h, so the average speed is lower than 50.
  • D. 75 is the total time in minutes, not a speed.
  • E. This uses 120 km for the distance, counting the round trip twice.

What carries over

Average speed is total distance over total time, never the mean of the speeds.

Question 2: Patients over 65

Problem solving: proportions

At a clinic, 35\frac{3}{5} of the patients registered are adults and the rest are children. A quarter of the adults are over 65. If 36 registered patients are over 65, how many patients are registered at the clinic?

Show the answer

Answer: D. 240

Working

Adults: 36×4=14436 \times 4 = 144. Adults are 35\frac{3}{5} of all patients, so the total is 144×53=240144 \times \frac{5}{3} = 240. Check by the share of the whole: over-65s are 35×14=320\frac{3}{5} \times \frac{1}{4} = \frac{3}{20} of the patients, and 320×240=36\frac{3}{20} \times 240 = 36.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A. This divides 36 by 35\frac{3}{5} and skips the step for the quarter of adults who are over 65.
  • B. This is the number of children, 25\frac{2}{5} of 240, not the total.
  • C. This is the number of adults (36×436 \times 4); the question asks for all registered patients.
  • E. This divides the 144 adults by 25\frac{2}{5}, the children's share, instead of by 35\frac{3}{5}.

What carries over

Multiply the fractions to get the share of the whole, then divide the known part by that share.

Question 3: Two pumps

Problem solving: rates

Pump P alone fills a tank in 6 hours. Pumps P and Q working together fill the same tank in 4 hours. How long would pump Q take to fill the tank alone?

Show the answer

Answer: E. 12 hours

Working

Rates in tanks per hour: together 14\frac{1}{4}, P alone 16\frac{1}{6}. Q's rate is 14−16=312−212=112\frac{1}{4} - \frac{1}{6} = \frac{3}{12} - \frac{2}{12} = \frac{1}{12}, so Q alone takes 12 hours. Check: in 12 hours P fills 2 tanks and Q fills 1, which is 3 tanks in 12 hours, one tank every 4 hours.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A. This subtracts the times, 6−46 - 4. Times do not add or subtract; rates do.
  • B. This is the time for two pumps of 6 and 4 hours working together, 6×46+4\frac{6 \times 4}{6 + 4}; but 4 hours is already the joint time, not Q's own time.
  • C. This averages the two times given, which has no meaning here.
  • D. This adds the two times given. Times do not add; only rates do.

What carries over

Convert times to rates, add or subtract the rates, and convert back.

Flashcards

Recall the answer before you flip each card, then say whether you knew it. Cards you miss come back at the end.

Average speed
Total distance divided by total time. It is not the mean of the speeds, because more time is spent at the slower speed.
Two workers or pumps together
Add their rates: 1a+1b\frac{1}{a} + \frac{1}{b} jobs per hour. Turn the combined rate back into a time at the end.
Overlapping groups formula
Total = A + B − both + neither. Adding A and B counts the overlap twice.
A ratio of 1 : 4
One part out of 5 in total. Add the parts of a ratio to get the whole before dividing.
Fraction of a fraction
Multiply to get the share of the whole: 35\frac{3}{5} of 14\frac{1}{4} is 320\frac{3}{20}. Divide the known part by its share to find the whole.
Checking a numerical answer
Run the answer forwards through the problem, and watch for options that equal an intermediate result.

Key points

  • Write the chain of quantities with their units before doing any arithmetic.

  • Work in fractions and cancel before multiplying; estimate to rule options out.

  • Rates add, times do not; average speed is total distance over total time.

  • For two overlapping groups, total = A + B − both + neither.

  • Wrong options are often intermediate results: reread the question before choosing.

All questions here are original and written for UniExamer; none comes from the test maker.

Written and reviewed by the UniExamer education and assessment team. Every worked example and check question was checked before publication. If you find a mistake, write to support@uniexamer.com.

Practise this topic

Fresh questions on this skill, with worked explanations. Practice needs a Single Exam Pass or Plus.