Lesson 7 of 46 · Logical reasoning and problems

Strengthening, weakening and flaws in arguments

Judge which new fact most strengthens or weakens an argument, and name the flaw in reasoning that moves from a link to a cause or reverses a rule.

About 22 minutes

In this lesson

  • Strengthen or weaken an argument by working on the gap between its evidence and its conclusion.
  • Recognise alternative explanations for a causal claim: reverse cause, a third factor and a biased comparison.
  • Name common reasoning flaws, including reversing a conditional and treating a necessary condition as sufficient.

The idea

Start from the gap

Strengthen, weaken and flaw questions all build on the previous lesson. Before you read the options, find the conclusion, find the evidence, and say in a few words what the argument takes for granted to get from one to the other. That gap is where every right answer acts.

  • An option strengthens the argument if it makes the gap smaller: it rules out a rival explanation or confirms something the argument assumed.
  • An option weakens the argument if it makes the gap wider: it offers a rival explanation for the evidence or shows an assumption is false.
  • A flaw is the gap itself, described in general terms: the kind of mistake the reasoning makes.

Two rules of the game. First, accept every option as true; the question is what it would do to the argument, not whether you believe it. Second, the question asks for the option that does the most: a small effect loses to a large one, and an option that is merely on the same topic does nothing.

Weakening a causal claim

Many arguments you will meet end in a claim that something causes something: a drug prevents colds, a tax reduces drinking, a garden speeds recovery. The evidence is usually that two things go together, or that a change was followed by another change. There are three standard ways the evidence can be explained without the claimed cause.

Rival explanation What it says Example
Reverse cause The effect produces the supposed cause Healthier people are more able to exercise, not only the other way round
Third factor Something else produces both Wealth could lead both to more gym use and to better health
Something else changed Another change at the same time explains the result A ward's recovery times fell when it also started taking easier cases

A strong weakener names one of these and makes it fit the facts in the passage. A strong strengthener rules one of them out, for example by showing that the groups compared were alike in every other way.

Comparisons and fair tests

Many medical and scientific arguments compare two groups. The comparison supports a causal conclusion only if the groups differ in the factor being studied and in nothing else that matters. That is why random assignment (chance decides who gets which treatment) and blinding (people do not know which treatment they have) strengthen a study so much: random assignment removes systematic differences between the groups, and blinding stops expectations from colouring what is reported. An option revealing that one group was healthier, younger or more motivated to begin with weakens the argument for the same reason.

Flaws to recognise

Flaw What the argument does
Link taken as cause Concludes that one thing causes another only because they occur together
Unrepresentative sample Generalises from a group that is not typical of the whole
Reversing a conditional From "all A are B" concludes "all B are A"
Necessary taken as sufficient Treats a condition that is required as if it guaranteed the result
Circular reasoning Uses the conclusion, reworded, as one of its premises
Attacking the person Rejects a claim because of who made it, not because of the evidence
False choice Presents two options as the only ones when others exist
Numbers and rates confused Compares totals when the groups differ in size, or the reverse

Reversing a conditional and confusing necessary with sufficient are close cousins. "Every nurse on the ward has a first-aid certificate" does not mean that everyone with a certificate is a nurse on the ward. "A certificate is required for the course" does not mean that having one gets you in. In both cases the argument reads a one-way rule as if it ran both ways.

How to read the options

  1. Find the conclusion and name the gap before you look at the options.
  2. For a weakener, look for the rival explanation; for a strengthener, look for what rules it out.
  3. Check direction: an option can be relevant and still push the wrong way. Bottled-water sales rising after a soft-drink tax fits the conclusion that people drink fewer soft drinks; it does not weaken it.
  4. Check scope: an option about other towns, other diseases or the cost of something usually leaves this argument untouched.
  5. For a flaw, match the general description to the specific step in the passage. A flaw option that describes a mistake the passage does not make is wrong, however familiar its wording.

Worked examples

Example 1: Weakening: the garden beside the ward

After a garden was opened beside ward A, the average stay of its patients fell from nine days to seven. The garden must have helped patients recover faster.

Which of these, if true, most weakens the argument? (i) Patients on ward A said they enjoyed the garden. (ii) In the same month the garden opened, ward A began admitting mainly patients recovering from minor operations.

  1. Conclusion: the garden caused faster recovery. Evidence: shorter average stays after it opened. Gap: nothing else changed that could shorten stays.

  2. Option (ii) names something else that changed at the same time: the ward's patients became easier cases, who would be expected to stay less long anyway. That explains the evidence without the garden.

  3. Option (i) is on the topic and even fits the conclusion, but enjoying a garden says nothing about whether it shortened stays. It does not weaken the argument.

Answer

Statement (ii) most weakens the argument, because it offers a rival explanation for the shorter stays. Statement (i) is tempting because it mentions the garden, but it has no bearing on the gap.

Example 2: Strengthening the same argument

Take the garden argument again, without option (ii). Which would most strengthen it? (i) Over the same period, ward B, which has no garden and admits the same kinds of patients as ward A, saw no change in its average stay. (ii) The garden was expensive to build.

  1. To strengthen a causal claim, rule out rival explanations. The biggest rival is that something affecting the whole hospital (a new discharge policy, a milder season) shortened stays everywhere.

  2. Option (i) supplies a comparison: a similar ward without a garden did not change. That makes a hospital-wide cause much less likely and points to something specific to ward A.

  3. Option (ii) is about cost. It has nothing to do with whether the garden shortened stays.

Answer

Statement (i) strengthens the argument by ruling out a hospital-wide explanation. It does not prove the garden caused the change, but a strengthener only has to make the conclusion more likely.

Example 3: Naming the flaw

To be accepted on the advanced training course, a nurse must hold a first-aid certificate. Luca holds a first-aid certificate, so he will be accepted on the course.

What is the flaw in this reasoning?

  1. Write the rule in the passage as a one-way statement: accepted on the course → holds a certificate. The certificate is a necessary condition.

  2. The argument uses it the other way round: holds a certificate → accepted. That treats the certificate as a sufficient condition, which the rule never said.

  3. Check with a counter-case: Luca could hold the certificate and still be turned down for another reason, such as too few places. Nothing in the passage rules that out.

Answer

The argument treats a necessary condition as if it were sufficient. Describing it as "it relies on an unrepresentative sample" or "it attacks the person" would be naming flaws that are not in the passage.

Common traps

  • Relevant but pointing the wrong way

    An option can be clearly about the argument and still strengthen when you were asked to weaken, or the reverse. Before choosing, say in one sentence what the option does to the gap: wider or narrower. Questions are often built so that the tempting option has the right topic and the wrong direction.

  • Doubting the option instead of using it

    Every option is to be taken as true. Rejecting an option because you think it is unlikely, or because you know a study that says otherwise, means answering a different question. Ask only what the option would do to this argument if it were true.

  • Choosing a familiar flaw that is not there

    Flaw options use standard labels, and a label you recognise feels right. Match each label to a specific step in the passage. If you cannot point to the sentence where the argument attacks a person or uses a small sample, that flaw is not the answer.

Check yourself

Choose an answer to each question: you will see at once whether it is right, and why.

Question 1: The soft-drink tax

Critical thinking: weaken

Since a city introduced a tax on sugary soft drinks, sales of those drinks in shops within the city have fallen by 20%. The city council concludes that the tax has reduced the amount of sugary soft drink that the city's residents drink.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the council's conclusion?

Show the answer

Answer: A. Since the tax was introduced, sales of sugary soft drinks in shops just outside the city boundary have risen sharply.

Working

The evidence is about sales in shops inside the city; the conclusion is about how much residents drink. The gap is that residents might simply buy the drinks elsewhere. A sharp rise in sales just outside the boundary offers that rival explanation for the 20% fall, so the fall need not mean residents drink less.

Why the other options are wrong

  • B. What the council expected does not change what happened; a smaller fall than forecast is still a fall, and it says nothing about where residents buy their drinks.
  • C. Other cities are outside the scope of the argument; this neither explains the fall in this city nor gives a reason to doubt it.
  • D. This fits the conclusion, since residents may have switched from soft drinks to water. It points the wrong way for a weakener.
  • E. This is background about the drinks. It has no bearing on whether residents now drink less of them.

What carries over

When the evidence measures one thing (sales in one place) and the conclusion another (consumption), the best weakener shows how they could come apart.

Question 2: The nasal-spray trial

Critical thinking: strengthen

During one winter, researchers gave one group of volunteers a new nasal spray and a second group a salt-water spray, each for a week. Over the following month, the volunteers in the first group reported 30% fewer colds than those in the second. The researchers conclude that the new spray helps to prevent colds.

Which of the following, if true, most strengthens the researchers' conclusion?

Show the answer

Answer: D. Volunteers were assigned to the groups at random, and neither they nor the researchers knew which spray each had received.

Working

The main threats to the conclusion are that the groups differed in some other way, and that volunteers who knew they had the new spray reported fewer colds because they expected to. Random assignment removes systematic differences between the groups, and blinding removes the effect of expectations on what is reported. Ruling out both rival explanations makes the spray the most likely cause.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A. Disliking the taste says nothing about whether the spray prevented colds; it does not touch the gap.
  • B. Both groups were studied in the same winter, so the season affects them equally and cannot explain the difference.
  • C. This weakens the conclusion: better general health is a rival explanation for the fewer colds.
  • E. Cost is irrelevant to whether the new spray prevents colds.

What carries over

A fair comparison strengthens a causal claim: random assignment and blinding rule out the commonest rival explanations.

Question 3: The rash and the painkiller

Critical thinking: flaw

A hospital audit found that every patient who developed a particular rash had been taking a new painkiller. A pharmacist concludes that every patient who takes the new painkiller will develop the rash.

Which of the following best describes the flaw in the pharmacist's reasoning?

Show the answer

Answer: C. From the fact that all patients with the rash took the painkiller, it concludes that all patients taking the painkiller will develop the rash.

Working

The audit establishes "rash → took the painkiller". The pharmacist concludes "took the painkiller → rash", the same rule run backwards. Many patients may take the painkiller without any rash; the audit, which looked only at patients with the rash, cannot tell. None of the other flaws named appears in the passage.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A. Nobody's claim is rejected and no person is criticised; the passage contains no attack on anyone.
  • B. The premise is about patients with the rash and the conclusion about patients taking the drug; they are different claims, so the reasoning is not circular.
  • D. The passage never offers a choice between two options, so there is no false choice to criticise.
  • E. The passage gives no numbers or group sizes at all, so it cannot be comparing totals unfairly.

What carries over

"All A are B" does not give "all B are A": check which way a rule runs before using it.

Flashcards

Recall the answer before you flip each card, then say whether you knew it. Cards you miss come back at the end.

Strengthener
A fact that narrows the gap between evidence and conclusion, usually by ruling out a rival explanation or confirming an assumption.
Weakener
A fact that widens the gap, usually by offering a rival explanation for the evidence or showing an assumption is false.
Three rival explanations for a causal claim
Reverse cause, a third factor that produces both, and another change that happened at the same time.
Why random assignment and blinding strengthen a study
Random assignment removes systematic differences between the groups; blinding stops expectations from affecting what is reported.
Reversing a conditional
Concluding "all B are A" from "all A are B". The rule runs only one way.
Necessary taken as sufficient
Treating a condition that is required, like a certificate for a course, as if it guaranteed the result.

Key points

  • Find the gap first: a strengthener narrows it, a weakener widens it, and a flaw describes it.

  • Treat every option as true and ask what it does to this argument, in which direction and by how much.

  • Causal claims are weakened by reverse cause, a third factor or another change at the same time.

  • Random assignment and blinding strengthen a comparison; a difference between the groups weakens it.

  • Reversing a one-way rule and treating a necessary condition as sufficient are two common logical flaws.

All questions here are original and written for UniExamer; none comes from the test maker.

Written and reviewed by the UniExamer education and assessment team. Every worked example and check question was checked before publication. If you find a mistake, write to support@uniexamer.com.

Practise this topic

Fresh questions on this skill, with worked explanations. Practice needs a Single Exam Pass or Plus.